The Art of Packing Light (or Not): Lessons from the Triple Crown Elite
There’s something almost mythical about the Triple Crown of thru-hiking—completing the Appalachian Trail, Pacific Crest Trail, and Continental Divide Trail. It’s a feat that fewer than 800 people have achieved, and it’s not just about physical endurance. It’s a masterclass in logistics, mental fortitude, and, perhaps most crucially, gear selection. Recently, a survey of 82 Triple Crowners revealed some fascinating insights into what they carried, why they carried it, and how their choices evolved. But what struck me most wasn’t the data itself—it was the philosophy behind it.
The Great Gear Debate: Light vs. Heavy
One thing that immediately stands out is the divide between hikers who swear by ultralight gear and those who advocate for carrying a bit more weight. Personally, I think this debate is less about right or wrong and more about understanding your own needs. What many people don’t realize is that the ultralight movement, while popular, isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution.
The survey showed that most Triple Crowners started with heavier packs (around 20.5 pounds) and gradually lightened their load to an average of 15.2 pounds by their final trail. This makes sense—as you hike more, you learn what’s essential and what’s just dead weight. But here’s the kicker: some hikers actually pushed back against the ultralight dogma. One hiker said, ‘Total weight doesn’t matter; just carry whatever you’re comfortable with.’ This raises a deeper question: Are we sacrificing comfort and enjoyment for the sake of a few ounces?
From my perspective, the key takeaway isn’t about how light or heavy your pack is, but about intentionality. If you’re carrying something, it should serve a purpose. As one hiker put it, ‘If you don’t use your gear at least once per day, then you don’t need to be carrying it.’ But equally, if a heavier item brings you joy—like a camp chair or a book—maybe it’s worth the extra weight.
The Gear That Stands the Test of Time
When it comes to specific gear, the survey revealed some clear favorites. Hyperlite Mountain Gear, Osprey, and Zpacks dominated the backpack and tent categories, respectively. What makes this particularly fascinating is that these brands aren’t just popular—they’re trusted. Triple Crowners put their gear through nearly 8,000 miles of abuse, so when they say something works, it’s worth listening.
But here’s where it gets interesting: the most popular gear isn’t always the newest or flashiest. Many hikers completed their Triple Crown over several decades, so the gear they recommend is often tried-and-true rather than cutting-edge. This suggests that durability and reliability trump novelty in the long run.
Footwear: The Most Personal Choice
If there’s one category where personal preference reigns supreme, it’s footwear. Altra, Topo Athletic, and Hoka One One were the top brands, but even within those, the models varied widely. What this really suggests is that feet are as unique as fingerprints. Just because a shoe worked for someone else doesn’t mean it’ll work for you.
This is a lesson I’ve learned the hard way. I once bought a pair of trail runners because they were highly recommended, only to develop blisters within the first 10 miles. Footwear is one area where you should trust your own experience over anyone else’s advice.
The Bigger Picture: What Gear Really Means
If you take a step back and think about it, gear isn’t just about functionality—it’s about mindset. The way you pack reflects how you approach the trail. Are you a minimalist who values speed and efficiency? Or do you prioritize comfort and enjoyment? There’s no right answer, but understanding your own priorities is crucial.
What many people don’t realize is that gear choices also reflect broader trends in hiking culture. The rise of ultralight gear, for example, mirrors a shift toward speed and efficiency. But there’s also a counter-movement of hikers who reject this mindset, opting for a slower, more deliberate pace. Both approaches are valid, but they represent fundamentally different ways of experiencing the trail.
Final Thoughts: The Gear That Matters Most
In the end, the most important piece of gear isn’t in your pack—it’s between your ears. The Triple Crowners’ advice boils down to this: trust yourself, adapt as you go, and don’t be afraid to make mistakes. Gear is a tool, not a rule.
Personally, I think the real lesson here is about balance. Yes, lighter gear can make hiking easier, but it’s not the only way to enjoy the trail. What matters most is finding what works for you. And if that means carrying a few extra Oreos—or even a camp chair—so be it. After all, the goal isn’t just to finish the trail; it’s to enjoy the journey along the way.
So, the next time you’re packing for a hike, remember: it’s not about the weight of your pack, but the weight of your experience. And that’s something no gear list can tell you.
